SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
GRANTED & NOTED LIST, OCTOBER TERM 2005
As of June 22, 2006
03-12381)* CFX IBP V. ALVAREZ
04-662 )* CFX TUM V. BARBER FOODS
Court: 1USCA-9; 2USCA-1 Grant: 2/22/05
Argument Date: 10/3/05 Decided: 11/8/05
Author: J. Stevens
Result: 1 AFFIRMED; 2 AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART,
AND REMANDED
04-52* CFH RICE V. COLLINS
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 6/28/05
Argument Date: 12/5/05 Decided: 1/18/06
Author: J. Kennedy Other: Breyer (C)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-373 CSY MARYLAND V. BLAKE
Court: CA-MD Grant: 4/18/05
Argument Date: 11/1/05 Decided: 11/14/05
Author: Per Curiam
Result: DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED
04-433 CFX ANZA V. IDEAL STEEL SUPPLY CORP.
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 11/28/05
Argument Date: 3/27/06 Decided: 6/5/06
Author: J. Kennedy Other: Scalia (C); Thomas (C/P, D/P)
Breyer (C/P, D/P)
Result: REVERSED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND REMANDED
04-473 CFX GARCETTI V. CEBALLOS
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 2/28/05
Argument Date: 10/12/05 Order for Reargument: 2/17/06
Reargument Date: 3/21/06 Decided: 5/30/06
Author: J. Kennedy Other: Stevens (D); Souter (D); Breyer (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-593* CFX DOMINO’S PIZZA V. McDONALD
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 4/25/05
Argument Date: 12/6/05 Decided: 2/22/06
Author: J. Scalia
Result: REVERSED (J. Alito – no part)
04-597 CFX UNITHERM FOOD SYSTEMS V. SWIFT ECKRICH
Court: USCA-Fed. Grant: 2/28/05
Argument Date: 11/2/05 Decided: 1/23/06
Author: J. Thomas Other: Stevens (D)
Result: REVERSED
04-607 CFX LABORATORY CORP. OF AMERICA V. METABOLITE LABORATORIES
Court: USCA-Fed. Grant: 10/31/05
Argument Date: 3/21/06 Decided: 6/22/06
Author: Per Curiam Other: Breyer (D)
Result: DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED
(Chief Justice – no part)
04-623 CFX GONZALES, ATTY. GEN. V. OREGON
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 2/22/05
Argument Date: 10/5/05 Decided: 1/17/06
Author: J. Kennedy Other: Scalia (D); Thomas (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-631 CFX WAGNON, SEC., DEPT. OF REVENUE V. PRAIRIE BAND POTAWATOMI
NATION
Court: USCA-10 Grant: 2/28/05
Argument Date: 10/3/05 Decided: 12/6/05
Author: J. Thomas Other: Ginsburg (D)
Result: REVERSED
04-698 CFX SCHAFFER V. WEAST
Court: USCA-4 Grant: 2/22/05
Argument Date: 10/5/05 Decided: 11/14/05
Author: J. O’Connor Other: Stevens (C); Ginsburg (D);
Breyer (D)
Result: AFFIRMED (Chief Justice – no part)
04-712* CFX LINCOLN PROPERTY CO. V. ROCHE
Court: USCA-4 Grant: 2/28/05
Argument Date: 10/11/05 Decided: 11/29/05
Author: J. Ginsburg
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-721# CFH EVANS V. CHAVIS
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 5/2/05
Argument Date: 11/9/05 Decided: 1/10/06
Author: J. Breyer Other: Stevens (C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-759* CFX UNITED STATES V. OLSON
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 3/7/05
Argument Date: 10/12/05 Decided: 11/8/05
Author: J. Breyer
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
04-805)* CFX TEXACO, INC. V. DAGHER
04-814)* CFX SHELL OIL CO. V. DAGHER
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 6/27/05
Argument Date: 1/10/06 Decided: 2/28/06
Author: J. Thomas
Result: REVERSED (J. Alito – no part)
04-848 CFX DOLAN V. U.S. POSTAL SERVICE
Court: USCA-3 Grant: 4/25/05
Argument Date: 11/7/05 Decided: 2/22/06
Author: J. Kennedy Other: Thomas (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-881*# CFX LOCKHART V. UNITED STATES
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 4/25/05
Argument Date: 11/2/05 Decided: 12/7/05
Author: J. O’Connor Other: Scalia (C)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-885 CFX CENTRAL VIRGINIA COMM. COLLEGE V. KATZ
Court: USCA-6 Grant: 4/4/05
Argument Date: 10/31/05 Decided: 1/23/06
Author: J. Stevens Other: Thomas (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-905 CFX VOLVO TRUCKS NORTH AMERICA, INC. V. REEDER-SIMCO GMC, INC.
Court: USCA-8 Grant: 3/7/05
Argument Date: 10/31/05 Decided: 1/10/06
Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Stevens (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-928# CSY OREGON V. GUZEK
Court: SC-OR Grant: 4/25/05
Argument Date: 12/7/05 Decided: 2/22/06
Author: J. Breyer Other: Scalia (C/J)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-944* CFX ARBAUGH V. Y&H CORP.
Court: USCA-5 Grant: 5/16/05
Argument Date: 1/11/06 Decided: 2/22/06
Author: J. Ginsburg
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-980 CFH BROWN V. SANDERS
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 3/28/05
Argument Date: 10/11/05 Decided: 1/11/06
Author: J. Scalia Other: Stevens (D); Breyer (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-1034) CFX RAPANOS V. UNITED STATES
04-1384) CFX CARABELL V. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS
Court: USCA-6 Grant: 10/11/05
Argument Date: 2/21/06 Decided: 6/19/06
Author: J. Scalia Other: Chief Justice (C)
Kennedy (C/J); Stevens (D)
Breyer (D)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
04-1067 CSY GEORGIA V. RANDOLPH
Court: SC-GA Grant: 4/18/05
Argument Date: 11/8/05 Decided: 3/22/06
Author: J. Souter Other: Stevens (C); Breyer (C);
Chief Justice (D); Scalia (D);
Thomas (D)
Result: AFFIRMED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1084* CFX GONZALES, ATTY. GEN. V. O CENTRO ESPIRITA ETC.
Court: USCA-10 Grant: 4/18/05
Argument Date: 11/1/05 Decided: 2/21/06
Author: Chief Justice (J. Alito – no part)
Result: AFFIRMED & REMANDED
04-1131 CFX WHITMAN V. DEPT. OF TRANSPORTATION
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 6/27/05
Argument Date: 12/5/05 Decided: 6/5/06
Author: Per Curiam
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1140* CFX MARTIN V. FRANKLIN CAPITAL CORPORATION
Court: USCA-10 Grant: 4/25/05
Argument Date: 11/8/05 Decided: 12/7/05
Author: Chief Justice
Result: AFFIRMED
04-1144* CFX AYOTTE, ATT’Y. GEN. OF NH V. PLANNED PARENTHOOD
Court: USCA-1 Grant: 5/23/05
Argument Date: 11/30/05 Decided: 1/18/06
Author: J. O’Connor
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
04-1152* CFX RUMSFELD, SEC. OF DEFENSE V. FORUM FOR ACADEMIC RIGHTS
Court: USCA-3 Grant: 5/2/05
Argument Date: 12/6/05 Decided: 3/6/06
Author: Chief Justice
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1170 CSY KANSAS V. MARSH
Court: SC-KS Grant: 5/31/05
Argument Date: 12/7/05 Order for Reargument: 3/24/06
Reargument Date: 4/25/06
04-1186* CFX WACHOVIA BANK, NAT. ASSN. V. SCHMIDT
Court: USCA-4 Grant: 6/13/05 (CT – no part)
Argument Date: 11/28/05 Decided: 1/17/06
Author: J. Ginsburg
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Thomas – no part)
04-1203)* CFX UNITED STATES V. GEORGIA
04-1236)* CFX GOODMAN V. GEORGIA
Court: USCA-11 Grant: 5/16/05
Argument Date: 11/9/05 Decided: 1/10/06
Author: J. Scalia Other: Stevens (C)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-1244)* CFX SCHEIDLER V. NOW
04-1352)* CFX OPERATION RESCUE V. NOW
Court: USCA-7 Grant: 6/28/05
Argument Date: 11/30/05 Decided: 2/28/06
Author: J. Breyer
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1264 CSX BUCKEYE CHECK CASHING V. CARDEGNA
Court: SC-FL Grant: 6/20/05
Argument Date: 11/29/05 Decided: 2/21/06
Author: J. Scalia Other: Thomas (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1324 CFH DAY V. McDONOUGH, INTERIM SEC., FL D.O.C.
Court: USCA-11 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 2/27/05 Decided: 4/25/06
Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Stevens (D/J); Scalia (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-1327* CSY HOLMES V. SOUTH CAROLINA
Court: SC-SC Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 2/22/06 Decided: 5/1/06
Author: J. Alito
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
04-1329* CFX ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS V. INDEPENDENT INK
Court: USCA-Fed. Grant: 6/20/05
Argument Date: 11/29/05 Decided: 3/1/06
Author: J. Stevens
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1332* CFX WILL V. HALLOCK
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 6/6/05
Argument Date: 11/28/05 Decided: 1/18/06
Author: J. Souter
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
04-1360 CSY HUDSON V. MICHIGAN
Court: CA-MI Grant: 6/27/05
Argument Date: 1/9/06 Order for Reargument: 4/21/06
Reargument Date: 5/18/06 Decided: 6/15/06
Author: J. Scalia Other: Kennedy (C/P, C/J)
Breyer (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-1371* CFX MERRILL LYNCH V. DABIT
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 1/18/06 Decided: 3/21/06
Author: J. Stevens
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1376 CFX FERNANDEZ-VARGAS V. GONZALES, ATTY. GEN.
Court: USCA-10 Grant: 10/31/05
Argument Date: 3/22/06 Decided: 6/22/06
Author: J. Souter Other: Stevens (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-1414# CFY UNITED STATES V. GRUBBS
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 1/18/06 Decided: 3/21/06
Author: J. Scalia Other: Souter (C/P, C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1477 CSX JONES V. FLOWERS
Court: SC-AR Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 1/17/06 Decided: 4/26/06
Author: Chief Justice Other: Thomas (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-1495 CFX HARTMAN V. MOORE
Court: USCA-DC Grant: 6/27/05
Argument Date: 1/10/06 Decided: 4/26/06
Author: J. Souter Other: Ginsburg (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (Chief Justice & J. Alito – no part)
04-1506* CFX ARKANSAS DEPT. OF HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES V. AHLBORN
Court: USCA-8 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 2/27/06 Decided: 5/1/06
Author: J. Stevens
Result: AFFIRMED
04-1527*# CSX S.D. WARREN CO. V. ME BD. OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION
Court: Supreme. Jud. Crt. of ME Grant: 10/11/05
Argument Date: 2/21/06 Decided: 5/15/06
Author: J. Souter
Result: AFFIRMED
04-1528) CFX RANDALL V. SORRELL
04-1530) CFX VERMONT REPUBLICAN STATE COMM. V. SORRELL
04-1697) CFX SORRELL V. RANDALL
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 2/28/06
04-1544# CFX MARSHALL V. MARSHALL
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 2/28/06 Decided: 5/1/06
Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Stevens (C/P, C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
04-1581 ATX WISCONSIN RIGHT TO LIFE V. FEC
Court: USDC-DC Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 1/17/06 Decided: 1/23/06
Author: Per Curiam
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
04-1618* CFX NORTHERN INSURANCE CO. OF NY V. CHATHAM CTY.
Court: USCA-11 Grant: 10/11/05
Argument Date: 3/1/06 Decided: 4/25/06
Author: J. Thomas
Result: REVERSED
04-1704)# CFX DAIMLErCHRYSLER CORP. V. CUNO
04-1724)# CFX WILKINS V. CUNO
Court: USCA-6 Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 3/1/06 Decided: 5/15/06
Author: Chief Justice Other: Ginsburg (C/P, C/J)
Result: VACATED IN PART AND REMANDED
04-1739 CFX BEARD V. BANKS, SEC., PA DOC
Court: USCA-3 Grant: 11/14/05
Argument Date: 3/27/06
04-8990 CFH HOUSE V. BELL
Court: USCA-6 Grant: 6/28/05
Argument Date: 1/11/06 Decided: 6/12/06
Author: J. Kennedy Other: C. J. (C/J/P, D/P)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (J. Alito – no part)
04-9728 CSY SAMSON V. CALIFORNIA
Court: CA, CA-1st Dist. Grant: 9/27/05
Argument Date: 2/22/06 Decided: 6/19/06
Author: J. Thomas Other: Stevens (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
04-105661) CSY SANCHEZ-LLAMAS V. OREGON
05-512 ) CSH BUSTILLO V. JOHNSON, DIR., VA DOC
Court: 1SC-OR; 2SC-VA Grant: 11/7/05
Argument Date: 3/29/06
05-18 CFX ARLINGTON CENTRAL SCHOOL DIST. BD. V. MURPHY
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 1/6/06
Argument Date: 4/19/06
05-83 CSY WASHINGTON V. RECUENCO
Court: SC-WA Grant: 10/17/05
Argument Date: 4/17/06
05-128 CFX HOWARD DELIVERY SERVICE V. ZURICH AMER. INSURANCE CO.
Court: USCA-4 Grant: 11/7/05
Argument Date: 3/21/06 Decided: 6/15/06
Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Kennedy (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
05-130* CFX EBAY INC. V. MERCEXCHANGE
Court: USCA-Fed. Grant: 11/28/05
Argument Date: 3/29/06 Decided: 5/15/06
Author: J. Thomas Other: Chief Justice (C),
Kennedy (C)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
05-184 CFX HAMDAN V. RUMSFELD, SEC. OF DEFENSE
Court: USCA-DC Grant: 11/7/05
Argument Date: 3/28/06
05-200 CFX EMPIRE HEALTHCHOICE ASSURANCE V. McVEIGH
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 1/6/06
Argument Date: 4/25/06 Decided: 6/15/06
Author: J. Ginsburg Other: Breyer (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
05-204) ATX LEAGUE OF UNITED LATIN V. PERRY GOV. TX
05-254) ATX TRAVIS COUNTY, TX V. PERRY, GOV. TX
05-276) ATX JACKSON V. PERRY, GOV. TX
05-439) ATX GI FORUM V. PERRY, GOV. TX
Court: USDC-E. TX Noted: 12/12/05
Argument Date: 3/1/06
05-259# CFX BURLINGTON NO. & SANTA FE R. V. WHITE
Court: USCA-6 Grant: 12/5/05
Argument Date: 4/17/06 Decided: 6/22/06
Author: J. Breyer Other: Alito (C/J)
Result: AFFIRMED
05-260* CFX SEREBOFF V. MID ATLANTIC MEDICAL SERVICES
Court: USCA-4 Grant: 11/28/05
Argument Date: 3/28/06 Decided: 5/15/06
Author: Chief Justice
Result: AFFIRMED IN RELEVANT PART
05-352 CFY UNITED STATES V. GONZALEZ-LOPEZ
Court: USCA-8 Grant: 1/6/06
Argument Date: 4/18/06
05-409 CFX KIRCHER V. PUTNAM FUNDS TRUST
Court: USCA-7 Grant: 1/6/06
Argument Date: 4/24/06 Decided: 6/15/06
Author: J. Souter Other: Scalia (C/P, C/J)
Result: VACATED AND REMANDED
05-416 CFX WOODFORD V. NGO
Court: USCA-9 Grant: 11/14/05
Argument Date: 3/22/06 Decided: 6/22/06
Author: J. Alito Other: Breyer (C/J); Stevens (D)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
05-465 CFX MOHAWK INDUSTRIES V. WILLIAMS
Court: USCA-11 Grant: 12/12/05
Argument Date: 4/26/06 Decided: 6/5/06
Author: Per Curiam
Result: DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED
05-502* CSY BRIGHAM CITY, UT V. STUART
Court: SC-UT Grant: 1/6/06
Argument Date: 4/24/06 Decided: 5/22/06
Author: Chief Justice Other: Stevens (C)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
05-5224 CSY DAVIS V. WASHINGTON
Court: SC-WA Grant: 10/31/05
Argument Date: 3/20/06 Decided: 6/19/06
(together with 05-5705)
Author: J. Scalia Other: Thomas (C/J/P, D/P)
Result: AFFIRMED (05-5705 reversed and remanded)
05-5705 CSY HAMMON V. INDIANA
Court: SC-IN Grant: 10/31/05
Argument Date: 3/20/06 Decided: 6/19/06
(together with 05-5224)
Author: J. Scalia Other: Thomas (C/J/P, D/P)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED (05-5224 affirmed)
05-5966 CSY CLARK V. ARIZONA
Court: CA-AZ, Div. 1 Grant: 12/5/05
Argument Date: 4/19/06
05-5992# CFY ZEDNER V. UNITED STATES
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 1/6/06
Argument Date: 4/18/06 Decided: 6/5/06
Author: J. Alito Other: Scalia (C/P, C/J)
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
05-7053 CFY DIXON V. UNITED STATES
Court: USCA-5 Grant: 1/13/06
Argument Date: 4/25/06 Decided: 6/22/06
Author: J. Stevens Other: Kennedy (C); Alito (C)
Breyer (D)
Result: AFFIRMED
05-8794* CFX HILL V. McDONOUGH, INTERIM SEC., FL DOC
Court: USCA-11 Grant: 1/25/06
Argument Date: 4/26/06 Decided: 6/12/06
Author: J. Kennedy
Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED
NOTE:
03-1559 CFX BANK OF CHINA, NY BRANCH V. NBM L.L.C.
Court: USCA-2 Grant: 6/27/05
Order: 11/15/05
Result: DISMISSED
* Unanimous Court
** Unanimous Court in Part
# Unanimous in Judgment
No. of Cases (Hours) made available for Argument: 88 (78.3 - not incl. reargument orders in 04-473, 04-1170, & 04-1360)
No. of Cases (Hours) argued: 87 (77.3 - not incl. rearguments; 03-1559 dismissed before argument)
Total Disposed of: Breakdown (no. in parentheses = no. of cases)
Signed Opinion/Judgment - 59 (66) Per Curiam - 5 (5) Dismissed - 1 (1) Other – ( )
CASE CODE KEY |
First Letter = Jurisdictional Grounds (ex. 99-804 CFY)
C - Certiorari
A - Appeal
Q - Certified Question
Second Letter = Court Below (ex. 99-804 CFY)
S - State
F - U.S. Court of Appeals
T - Three-Judge District Court
M - U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces
O - Other Court
Third Letter = Nature of Case (ex. 99-804 CFY)
X - Civil
Y - Criminal
H - Habeas Corpus or other collateral attack